Loved by 50k users with⭐4.9 rating
Why You’ll Love This Recipe
- You get risen, crispy Yorkshire pudding batter every time thanks to the hot oil and a foolproof method.
- The whole recipe takes under an hour from start to finish, with only ten minutes’ hands-on work.
- Each serving of this toad in the hole delivers around 22 g of protein, more than the two Aunt Bessie’s packs compared below.
- Easy swaps make it suitable for vegetarian and child-friendly meals, with clear allergen guidance.
- The comforting flavour and the classic pairing with onion gravy, mash and veg make it a satisfying British crowd-pleaser.
🛒 Why this version is better than shop-bought: salt, protein, fat and what you get for your money
Making toad in the hole yourself gives you control over the two things that decide its nutrition: the batter and the sausages. The batter is only flour, eggs, milk and a pinch of salt. The eight sausages supply most of the fat and salt, so they are where you win or lose.
With standard pork sausages of about 80% meat, a homemade serving carries more fat and a little more salt than the chilled packs compared below. Protein is level with the best of them. Reduced-fat or lower-salt sausages change that picture, and a ready meal never lets you make that choice.
Sausages with at least 80% meat also keep the batter crisp. Cheaper, filler-heavy ones shrink and release water into the batter.
Lower salt than most chilled ready meals
Chilled packs show 1.51 g salt in a 222 g Hearty Food Co. portion and 1.7 g in a 190 g Aunt Bessie’s pack. A homemade serving with standard sausages comes in at about 2 g, so the sausages decide whether you beat them. Compare the salt per 100 g on two or three sausage packs and buy the lowest. Keep the batter to a pinch.
Higher protein from eggs and quality sausages
Four eggs and eight sausages give a serving about 22 g protein, against 12 to 13 g in the two Aunt Bessie’s packs. The Hearty Food Co. pack matches it at 21.2 g, so the gain is over some packs, not all. High-meat sausages are what keep this figure up.
Less processed ingredients and additives
The homemade list has five items: flour, eggs, milk, sausages and oil. Sausages and packs can carry permitted preservatives, stabilisers or flavourings, and which ones depends on the brand. Read the ingredient list for E numbers, and use our guide to food additives and E-numbers to see what each one does.
Comforting flavour and texture at a lower cost per portion
Sausages are the biggest cost. The flour, four eggs, 200 ml milk and oil are cupboard staples used in small amounts. Add up your receipt for the sausages and those staples, divide by four, and set the result against the shelf price of one pack portion to see your own saving.
⏱️ At a glance: homemade vs supermarket toad in the hole
Shop packs run 190 to 222 g per portion, and the gap to homemade is widest on fat and salt, not protein. This table compares one portion of each, as served: lower is better for energy, fat and salt, and higher is better for protein.
| Option | Portion | Energy (kcal) | Protein (g) | Fat (g) | Salt (g) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| This recipe, 1 serving | ¼ of the dish | 500-550 | 22 | 35 | 2 |
| Hearty Food Co. Toad in the Hole (Tesco) | 222 g | 499 | 21.2 | 18.1 | 1.51 |
| Aunt Bessie’s Toad in the Hole Ready Meal | 190 g | 382 | 13 | 19 | 1.7 |
| Aunt Bessie’s Meat Free Toad in the Hole | 190 g | 375 | 12 | 21 | 1.5 |
| Tesco Slow Cooked Sausage in Onion Gravy (no batter) | 265 g | 581 | 28.9 | 41.2 | 1.41 |
What this shows: With standard sausages, this recipe has nearly double the fat of the three toad in the hole packs (35 g against 18 to 21 g) and about a third more salt than the Hearty pack. Its protein matches Hearty’s and is about 9 to 10 g above Aunt Bessie’s. Treat it as an occasional comfort meal, and pick sausages with the lowest fat and salt per 100 g.
🧺 Ingredients, with swaps that keep the texture
A classic toad in the hole uses 140 g plain flour, 4 eggs, 200 ml milk, 8 sausages and 45 ml fat for a 20 x 30 cm metal tin. Any swap must keep the bind and the rise.
Each swap below keeps the method unchanged.
| Ingredient to swap | Use instead, and how much | What changes |
|---|---|---|
| Pork sausages | 8 vegetarian sausages such as Linda McCartney, Quorn or Richmond Meat-Free | Same shape and bake time; about 350-400 kcal per serving |
| Plain flour | 140 g certified gluten-free plain flour | Rise may be slightly lower; check the sausage label too |
| Eggs, milk and sausages (vegan) | Vegan sausages, 200 ml oat or soya drink, and a commercial egg replacer made up as the pack says for 4 eggs | Rise is lower |
| Whole milk | 200 ml oat, soya or almond drink | Removes dairy; flavour is slightly different |
| Pork sausages | 8 chicken sausages or chipolatas, same weight | Fat and salt vary by brand, so check per 100 g; thinner sausages brown faster |
| Standard sausages | Reduced-fat or lower-salt sausages, same number | Cuts the fat and salt that come mostly from the sausages |
| Beef dripping | 45 ml vegetable oil | Suits vegetarians |
This recipe contains gluten (wheat), egg and milk. The allergies section below covers sausage labels and safe swaps.
🥄 Toad in the hole: step-by-step method for crisp batter and juicy sausages
Rest the batter for 30 minutes, then pour it into fat hot enough to sizzle: those two habits decide the rise.
-
1Step 1Sift the flour and salt into a bowl, make a well, crack in the eggs and whisk, drawing in the flour. Pour in the milk slowly, whisking until smooth like single cream.
-
2Step 2 ⏱️ 30 minutesCover the batter and rest it at room temperature for 30 minutes. This relaxes the gluten and helps the rise. You can skip it when short of time, with a slightly lower rise.
-
3Step 3Heat the oven to 220°C (200°C fan), Gas Mark 7, while the batter rests.
-
4Step 4 ⏱️ 10-15 minutesPut the sausages and oil in the metal tin and roast for 10-15 minutes until the sausages start to brown and the fat is very hot.
-
5Step 5Take the tin out carefully, give the batter a quick whisk and pour it around the sausages in one go. It should sizzle at once. Return the tin to the oven immediately.
-
6Step 6 ⏱️ 25-30 minutesBake for 25-30 minutes without opening the door. The batter should be risen, golden and crisp at the edges, with a softer centre that is set, not wet or sticky.
-
7Step 7Serve straight away while puffed. It deflates a little as it cools, which is normal.
💡 Top tip: Before pouring in the batter, flick a few drops into the tin. If they do not sizzle straight away, put the tin back in the oven for a few more minutes. Pouring into fat that is not hot enough is what gives a flat, soggy base.
👨👩👧👦 Make it work for your family: scaling, making ahead and remix versions
You can halve the recipe (70 g flour, 2 eggs, 100 ml milk, 4 sausages) or double it across two 20 x 30 cm tins rather than one deep one. For individual toads, use a muffin tin with one sausage per hole and divide the batter between 8 holes. Bake for 20-25 minutes.
You can make the batter the night before and keep it in the fridge. Let it come back to room temperature before use, because cold batter in hot fat rises less.
For children, cut sausages into small pieces and give a smaller wedge with extra vegetables. Scattering sliced onions around the sausages before the batter goes in adds sweetness as they caramelise.
🥗 Nutrition per portion against official salt and protein guidance
A serving of this recipe (a quarter of the dish, without gravy or sides) gives about 500-550 kcal, 22 g protein and 2 g salt, around a quarter of the 2,000 kcal adult reference intake. A British Dietetic Association recipe made with reduced-fat sausages gives 358 kcal, 13 g fat, 20 g protein and 1.2 g salt in a 191 g portion, about a fifth of that reference intake. Most of the salt comes from the sausages, so their fat and salt move these numbers more than anything else.
Toddlers and young children: portion size, salt and safety
Toad in the hole is not suitable for babies under 1 year because of the salt in sausages. For toddlers, serve a small portion with plenty of vegetables and cut the sausage into small pieces to reduce the choking risk.
🥗 Nutrition example: A 2-year-old’s portion of one-eighth of the dish is one sausage with its share of batter, half an adult serving. From this recipe’s figures that is about 250-275 kcal, 11 g protein and 1 g salt. Lower-salt sausages are the easiest way to bring that salt down.
For blood sugar and diabetes: balancing the batter and sides
Most of the carbohydrate, about 28 g a serving, comes from the flour and milk, and batter is a quick-digesting starch. If you count carbohydrate, treat that as a starting point, since sausage choice shifts it. Serve a moderate portion with extra vegetables such as peas or greens rather than adding mash.
Pregnancy: what matters with sausages and batter
Cook the sausages until no pink remains and the batter is set in the middle, and follow the timings on the sausage pack. Check the sausage ingredient list for wheat, egg, milk, soya and sulphites.
Allergies: gluten, egg, milk and safe swaps
The classic recipe contains wheat (gluten), egg and milk. Sausages can add soya or sulphites (declared when above 10 mg/kg), and on packaged food UK law requires allergens to be emphasised in the ingredient list, usually in bold. Gluten-free flour alone does not make the dish safe for coeliac disease: the sausages and cross-contact must be checked too. “May contain” statements are voluntary, so read them as a warning.
🧊 Storage, reheating and serving: keeping toad in the hole safe, fresh and balanced
Cool leftovers quickly, cover them and keep them in the fridge for up to 2 days. Reheat portions in the oven at 180°C for 10-15 minutes until piping hot. The batter will not be as crisp as fresh, and a microwave makes it soft.
To freeze, portion the cooked toad in the hole, wrap it well and freeze for up to 3 months. Reheat from frozen at 180°C for 25-30 minutes.
✅ Quick check:
- Steaming hot all the way through, including the centre
- Reheated only once
- Covered in the fridge and eaten within 2 days
- Thrown away if in doubt
When you restock sausages for the next batch, scanning the packs in GoodFor shows salt and saturated fat per 100 g, with the reasons behind each score.
🧑🍳 Common mistakes and how to fix them
Most failures trace back to the hot-fat step or the closed door in the method above. Work out which one it was from what the dish looks like, and fix that one next time. Some cooks open the oven briefly once the batter has set, so the “no peeking” rule matters most in the first 25 minutes.
Why did my batter not rise or turn out soggy?
A heavy, wet centre with pale edges means the fat or tin was not hot enough. Use a metal tin, heat the oven to 220°C (200°C fan) and wait for the sizzle. If the batter sizzled but stayed flat, the oven may be cooler than its dial says, or the door was opened early.
⚠️ Watch out: Opening the oven in the first 25 minutes lets out the heat and the risen batter collapses. Use the oven light and only check once the batter looks golden and set.
What to do if your batter collapses, sticks or cooks unevenly
Crowding sausages in a tin that is too small, or pouring slowly, causes sticking and an uneven bake. Use a 20 x 30 cm tin, brown the sausages first and pour the batter in one go. Avoid cold batter, and serve at once while it is puffed.
Nutrition And GoodFor Score
The figures above are estimates calculated from the ingredient list using standard pork sausages of about 80% meat. A serving also has about 35 g fat (12 g saturates), 28 g carbohydrate and 1 g fibre, and your own sausages move the fat and salt most. GoodFor is a UK food and drink scanning app used by thousands of users. It scores a recipe from its full ingredient list, shows Nutri-Score, NOVA group and a 0-100 score with every deduction listed, and flags allergens such as gluten, eggs and dairy for each family profile. Scanning the sausage packs shows how they change the result.
Every scan gets one 0-100 score. Each part is shown so you can see why a product scored what it did.
- 🥣
Nutritional value22/40
- 🍃
Ingredients20/20
- 🛡️
Allergens and your profile15/15
- 🧪
Additives15/15
- 🏭
Processing10/10
NOVA groups food by how processed it is, from 1 (unprocessed) to 4 (ultra-processed). GoodFor flags the group on every scan.
Nutri-Score grades the overall nutritional quality of a food from A (best) to E, per 100 g. GoodFor shows it on every scan.
Frequently Asked Questions
How long does toad in the hole take from start to finish?
Allow 45 to 80 minutes in total. That is 10 minutes of prep, 35 to 40 minutes in the oven and an optional 30-minute rest for the batter. Start heating the oven while the batter rests so the tin is ready when it finishes. Skipping the rest brings the total near 45 minutes.
What do you serve with toad in the hole?
Serve it with onion gravy, mash and a green vegetable. For gravy, cook sliced onions slowly until caramelised, add beef stock and a splash of red wine, then thicken with flour or cornflour. Mash with butter and milk, and steam or roast peas, carrots, green beans or broccoli. Baked beans are the traditional shortcut. If you buy gravy, GoodFor shows its salt and additives before it goes in the trolley.
Can I flavour the batter?
Yes: stir 1 teaspoon of dried thyme, rosemary or sage into the batter before resting it. For sweetness, scatter sliced onions around the sausages just before the batter goes in. They caramelise in the fat as it bakes.
Should I use dripping or vegetable oil?
Use 45 ml (3 tbsp) of either, measured into the tin with the sausages. Dripping is beef fat, so choose vegetable oil for a vegetarian version. The British Dietetic Association recipe gets by with just 15 ml of sunflower oil alongside reduced-fat sausages. Ask Lumi, the GoodFor food coach, for lower-fat sausage ideas that fit your family’s goals.
Can I use a glass or ceramic dish?
Use a metal tin about 20 x 30 cm if you can. Metal conducts heat better, so the fat gets hotter and the batter crisps and rises more. A glass or ceramic dish heats more slowly, so expect a paler, softer result. If it is all you have, give the sausages the full 15 minutes before pouring in the batter.
Can I use semi-skimmed milk?
Yes, use 200 ml semi-skimmed in place of whole milk with the same method. It removes a little fat, but the saving is small because the sausages supply most of the dish’s fat. If you want a bigger change, swap the sausages for reduced-fat ones instead.
🛒 Next time you shop or cook toad in the hole, do these three things
- Compare sausages for fat and salt per 100 g and choose the ones lowest in both to control the whole dish.
- Rest the batter for 30 minutes and pour it into fat that is sizzling hot for maximum rise and crisp edges.
- Use a metal tin and avoid opening the oven in the first 25 minutes to keep the batter puffed and light.
📚 Sources (3)
Score your toad in the hole before you cook.
Scan your sausage, flour and milk in GoodFor free to see the nutrition, allergens and swaps for vegetarian or child-friendly versions, all in seconds.
- Check the salt, fat and additives in any sausage pack.
- See swaps for vegetarian, lower-fat or child-friendly meals.
- Scan in any UK shop—no weighing or typing needed.
Free · No ads · Trusted by thousands of users








